Skip to main content
Sercxi

Adjudication · Practice Note

Two Models. One of Them Is Built for Speed, Not Fit.

Running a critical seat on contingency does not save fees. It quietly signals to the market that the mandate is optional — and the operators you actually want will not engage on those terms.

Sercxi runs engaged, partner-led searches only, with no shared desk. That structure produces different outcomes from contingency search. This page states the difference plainly. Where numbers appear, they are sourced. Where the honest answer is a range, it is written as a range, not as false precision.

The fee argument

A contingency fee buys you a submission. An engaged fee buys you the search itself — the mapping, the refusals, the calibration, and the willingness to tell you the brief is wrong before we open it.

DimensionContingency SearchSercxi (Engaged)
Mandate load per partnerTypically higher — contingency models usually spread effort across many open searches.¹Partner-led throughout; engaged mandates only.
Fee structurePaid only on placement — incentive to close fast.Engaged — incentive to close right.
Candidate exclusivitySame candidate frequently submitted by multiple firms.Single-sourced. No cross-firm submission.
Time to shortlistVaries with how many firms are working the same role; no comparable published figure.21 working days to shortlist; median of 35 working days to offer.
12-month retentionNo comparable published 12-month figure is cited here.8 in 10 still in role after 12 months, in a measured cohort of placements (not every assignment).
Search terminationRare — sunk cost keeps searches open indefinitely.Mandate can be declined or ended if the fit is not there.

Where engaged is and isn't the right model

Engaged search costs more upfront. That is not a caveat, it is the point. It is the right model when the role is complexity-stage, when the cost of a mis-hire is measured in quarters of lost momentum, and when the candidate you actually need is not currently on the market.

It is the wrong model for high-volume hiring, for roles where a shortlist of active applicants is sufficient, or for organisations that need embedded scale rather than a single senior appointment. For that pattern, an internal team supported by a repeatable method usually outperforms any external firm — which is the case for our Executive Hiring Lab.

If the mandate is critical and singular, engaged is worth it. If it is neither, it is not. Both answers are fine — the wrong answer is choosing the model that fits the fee structure of the firm you already know, rather than the shape of the hire in front of you.

If a specific mandate is in view, initiate a confidential briefing. If the answer for your situation is the Lab instead of engaged search, we will say so on the call.

Sources

  1. AESC (Association of Executive Search and Leadership Consultants) — Global Executive Search Industry reports document the structural workload difference between retained (engaged) and contingency models. Reference ↗

Sercxi figures are firm-reported historical results, not guarantees; see the Track Record for definitions.